The smart way to pick the best places to eat, stay, shop, and play because you are the critic! It is truly the people's choice!

Washington States Tops California in Blind Tasting P306
 
Update: An article has been published in the June 2001 issue of Wine Enthusiast written by Paul Gregutt. The page 15 article, titled "Taste Washington" confirmed the Wine Club story. Per the article, a similar "Taste Washington" event was held in Miami, FL, favoring the California wines slightly. The Gordon Brothers wine came in 2nd behind the Opus One. The Caymus Cab came in 3rd. The DeLille Cellars entry came in 4th, and Col Solare 5th. The 6th, 7th and 8th picks were the same. LL - 5/20/01
 
Reprint of an article in the Selah Market Wine Club April, 2001 newsletter
   
How would you like to wake up one day and find everything going your way? That was the way a bunch of Washington Winemakers felt when their reds trounced some of the world's best at a dramatic blind tasting in San Francisco recently. Industry and media participants ranked eight cabernet or cabernet-based wines from the 1996, 1997, and 1998 vintages of Bordeaux, California, and Washington State respectively.

"We were just thrilled to be included in that tasting," said Jeff Gordon, one of the partners in Gordon Brothers (from the Columbia Valley).

Turns out Gordon Brothers had a little more to be thrilled about.

The Gordon Brothers' "1998 Tradition: - a Bordeaux-style blend of 56 percent cabernet and 44 percent merlot, aged in one to three-year-old French oak barrels, and created by their French-bred winemaker, Marie-Eve Gilla--came out on top, besting the likes of Opus One, Chateau Mouton Rothschild and Caymus.

"This was a room full of Californians, mind you," said Steve Burns, executive director of the Washington Wine Commission. "They weren't too pleased with the results. They said they felt like they were set up, but we said: 'Ladies and gentlemen, you tasted them, you picked them.'"

The final ranking:

1. Gordon Brothers (WA), '98 Tradition, available August 2001, $42.99

2. DeLille Cellars (WA), '98 Chaleur Estate, in-stock, $48.99

3. Col Solare (WA), '98 Red Table Wine, coming soon, $70.00

4. Opus One (CA), '97 Red Wine, upon request, $140.00

5. Caymus (CA), '97 Cabernet, in-stock, $69.99

6. Quilceda Creek (WA), '98 Cabernet, coming soon, $65.00

7. Chateau Cos d'Estournel (FR) '96, upon request

8. Chateau Mouton-Rothschild (FR) '96, upon request

"To level the playing field we chose superior vintages from each appellation," said Burns. "This blind taste-off is another indicator of the quality wines being produced in Washington State."

Gordon Brothers' 95-acre vineyard thrives on the sun-drenched, river-moderated slopes overlooking the Snake River in the Columbia Valley appellation of Washington State. Gordon uses 45 percent of his own grapes in his estate wines and the demand for remaining grapes exceeds supply. "We believe when people discover a new wine region, they look for individual vineyards of the area to identify the unique characteristics and flavors of the wines produced from that vineyard. Because we only use fruit from our own vineyard, one can be assured that the uniqueness of the wine will be preserved from one vintage to the next."

Total production of the 1998 Tradition is 400 cases to be released later this year. We hope to get additional allocation for our "Wine Club members. For more information on Gordon Brothers, or any of the wines listed, contact J.J., at Selah Market, at 509 697-6100.

 
Washington States Tops California in Blind Tasting  
Selah Market, Wine Club, P.O. Box 520, Selah, WA 98942-0520
Phone: 509 961-3515  
Reprinted here by permission Rcvd: 4/30/2001
Submitted by: LL, Yakima, WA C1  
Critiques from readers represent the views of the writer and do not reflect any opinion by . Similarly, advertisement from advertisers represent the views of the advertiser and do not reflect any endorsement by .
 
Help us grow!
Copyright © 2000, 1999 . All rights reserved. Information in this document is subject to change without notice.
Other products and companies referred to herein are trademarks or registered trademarks of their respective companies or mark holders.
updated 5/20/2001 Comments & suggestions to: webmaster@criticsatlarge.com